• Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
Friday, March 24, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
Business Post
E3P Motor Insurance
  • Home
  • Insurance
  • Pension
  • Business Unlimited
  • OIL & ENERGY
  • Feature
  • News
  • Home
  • Insurance
  • Pension
  • Business Unlimited
  • OIL & ENERGY
  • Feature
  • News
No Result
View All Result
Business Post
No Result
View All Result
Home OIL & ENERGY

Okpabi v Shell: The Era Of Unbridled Corporate Impunity Drawing To A Close

Nwanne Ikemefune by Nwanne Ikemefune
March 19, 2021
in OIL & ENERGY
0 0
1
Oil Spill in Niger Delta
0
SHARES
104
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsApp

For communities around the world who have been powerless to hold abusive corporations to account, some recent court judgments provide real hope.

Shell. An oil spill in Ogoniland in the Niger Delta, Nigeria. Credit: Luka Tomac/Friends of the Earth International.

An oil spill in Ogoniland in the Niger Delta, Nigeria. Credit: Luka Tomac/Friends of the Earth International.

On 12 February 2021, the UK Supreme Court ruled that the Anglo-Dutch oil giant Shell can be sued in the English courts by two Nigerian communities which have been devastated by decades of oil pollution.

The judgment represents a watershed moment in the fight for corporate accountability. The Supreme Court has now unanimously confirmed in both Okpabi v Shell and its earlier decision in 2019 in Lungowe v Vedanta that parent companies can be held legally responsible for harms committed by their foreign subsidiaries. Reaching this point has taken years of litigation. In Okpabi, there was a five-year legal battle in which Shell argued that it could not be held legally responsible in the UK for the failings of its Nigerian subsidiary.  Parallel litigation in the Netherlands has taken over a decade, culminating in the recent decision of the Dutch Court of Appeal which found Shell liable for pollution of two Nigerian communities.

These judgments have now set out the legal framework for the foreseeable future and pave the way for more international human rights and environmental ligation in British courts against abusive corporations. For communities around the world who have been powerless to hold corporations to account, these judgments provide real hope.

Corporate impunity

Few situations exemplify the current challenge of corporate impunity as starkly as the widespread and systematic oil pollution in Nigeria. Experts estimate that the inhabitants of the Niger Delta have experienced oil spills on a par with the 1989 Exxon Valdez disaster in Alaska every year for the past 50 years, a yearly average of about 240,000 barrels.

These statistics mask a human tragedy on an extraordinary scale. The pollution is ingested by local communities and seriously impacts human health and mortality rates. A recent study by the University of St Gallen in Switzerland found that infants in the Niger Delta are twice as likely to die in their first month of life if their mothers live near an oil spill. That amounts to a scandalous 11,000 premature deaths per year.

The situation is particularly dire in Ogoniland, from where Ken Saro-Wiwa led his fight against Shell in the early-1990s. In 2011, the United Nations Environment Programme’s (UNEP) Environmental Assessment of Ogoniland reported how the Ogoni people were exposed to severe oil contamination on a daily basis, impacting their water sources, air quality, and farmland.

Public health was found to be significantly at risk. At the time the report was published signs were erected around the impacted communities which made it clear that the drinking water was unfit for human consumption and vast areas of land and waterways were unsafe. UNEP recommended that urgent steps should be taken to ensure “the largest terrestrial clean-up operation in history”. Shockingly, ten years on, the communities remain polluted, no clean-up has occurred and their residents are still drinking from poisoned wells.  The signs which once warned people of the chronic pollution are now rusty and barely visible.

Why is this human tragedy allowed to persist while Western oil majors continue to profit?  The short answer is that the weak regulatory regime gives space to avaricious corporations who fail to maintain and invest in their infrastructure or clean up their oil spills.

As a result, hundreds of polluted communities which host the infrastructure of oil majors have been left polluted, uncleaned and uncompensated for decades. Given the hopeless prospect of accessing justice for these abuses in Nigeria, these communities are increasingly seeking redress in the Global North against the parent companies who reap the rewards of their Nigerian oil operations.

Holding parent companies to account

The Ogale and Bille communities, whose 50,000 residents have suffered from decades of oil pollution, instructed Leigh Day in 2016 to sue Shell in London and to seek clean-up and compensation for the loss of their livelihoods. The communities argued that Shell exercised supervision, direction, and control over Shell Nigeria and that it was therefore directly liable for its subsidiaries’ failures.

In response, Shell contended that the connection between parent company and subsidiary was so remote that it acted as little more than a shareholder. It tried to persuade the courts that the parent company itself had no real involvement in Nigeria, and any evidence of guidance or direction which was transmitted to Shell Nigeria from the chain of command was from other Shell entities, not the parent company. At the same time, Shell refused to disclose any internal documentation which would explain the reality of how the parent related to its subsidiary.

Both the UK High Court and the Court of Appeal were convinced by Shell’s arguments and dismissed the communities’ case at the jurisdiction stage.  The Court of Appeal ruled that the claimants needed to show there was clear evidence of “operational control”, which unsurprisingly they were unable to do without access to internal corporate documents. It also held that global policy frameworks which flow down from parent companies, could never give rise to legal liability as a matter of principle.

The Supreme Court this February disagreed. It unanimously overturned the Court of Appeal and found that there was a good arguable case against Shell. The judges ruled that the lower courts had jumped the gun by conducting a mini-trial before disclosure and witness evidence had come into play. Further, they had failed to consider the “obvious importance” of internal documents which would shed light on the true nature of the corporate relationships.

Importantly, the Supreme Court rejected the restrictive test for liability which had been adopted by the Court of Appeal. Parent company liability does not only arise if there is a relationship of “control”; it could also arise if there is supervision, advice, and other forms of intervention which fall short of control. That could include global policy frameworks, which could be flawed and thereby give rise to harm. Significantly, the Supreme Court held that public undertakings by a parent company could also give rise to a legal duty if it fails to follow through. It would seem that the Supreme Court expects multinationals to honour their commitments.

Of course, the Niger Delta is an example of a much wider problem of endemic corporate impunity in the Global South. The Supreme Court’s judgment will have widespread ramifications for corporate accountability and will be relied upon by marginalised communities in courts around the world.

This development comes alongside important legal initiatives in the EU which will oblige corporations to conduct human rights due diligence with regard to their subsidiaries and their supply chains. The era of unbridled corporate impunity is drawing to a close. For impacted communities around the world, that is long overdue.

Source: African Arguments By Daniel Leader
Previous Post

Opportunities And Vulnerabilities, Marker To Define Insurance Market Pulse

Next Post

Insurance Market Sets For Nigerian Code Of Corporate Governance

Nwanne Ikemefune

Nwanne Ikemefune

Related Posts

Seplat Energy Says Allegations Against CEO, Board Untrue, Misleading
OIL & ENERGY

Seplat Energy Says Allegations Against CEO, Board Untrue, Misleading

March 16, 2023
Crude Oil Gains
OIL & ENERGY

OPEC+ Agrees To Cut Oil Output By 2million Barrels Per Day

October 7, 2022
NAICOM, Local Content Board Make Oil & Gas Risks Runway Too Short For Offshore Take Off
OIL & ENERGY

NAICOM, Local Content Board Make Oil & Gas Risks Runway Too Short For Offshore Take Off

June 10, 2022
Next Post
NAICOM Head office

Insurance Market Sets For Nigerian Code Of Corporate Governance

Comments 1

  1. v says:
    1 week ago

    Hmm it looks like your blog ate my first comment (it was super
    long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughuly enjoyying
    your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer buut I’m still new tto
    the whole thing. Do you have anny helpful hinnts for beginner blog writers?
    I’d genuinely appreciate it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NEM INSURANCE NEM INSURANCE NEM INSURANCE
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
ILAN Picture

Loss Adjusters Receive Charge To Match Speed Of New Developments

July 30, 2022
Custodian Investment To Acquire 51% Stake In UACN Property

Penetration: Operators Call For Insurance-In-Action

November 2, 2022
tope smart NIA former chairman

Insurance Milestone: A Beacon To Follow

April 3, 2022
ncrib logo

NCRIB And Universal In Pictures

August 23, 2020
Reinsurance Rates May Increase Into 2022, But Momentum To Wane: Fitch

Reinsurance Rates May Increase Into 2022, But Momentum To Wane: Fitch

April 13, 2021
Preferred PenCom Logo

PenCom Board Crafted To Hedge Setback

February 1, 2021
Linkage Assurance Aligns With Brokers For Growth

Linkage Assurance Aligns With Brokers For Growth

December 6, 2021
NCRIB Sets The Stage For Adaramola’s Tenure

NCRIB Sets The Stage For Adaramola’s Tenure

March 18, 2021
PenCom Approves Mrs Okwuosa New Access Pension Fund Custodian MD

PenCom Board Back-To-Work Pass, Gets Tick Over

February 1, 2021
PTAD Wipes 21,227 Parastatals Pensioners From Payroll

PTAD Wipes 21,227 Parastatals Pensioners From Payroll

January 31, 2021
Scib CEO Tinubu

Professionals Want Value Dimension Added To Enhance Compulsory Insurance

6395
How Strong Is The Reinsurance Sector Going Into 2021?

How Strong Is The Reinsurance Sector Going Into 2021?

6126
Allianz Claims Survey Shows Changing Claims Patterns

Internal Failures, Major Cause Of Cyber Claims

5157
As Nat Cat Losses Mount A Resilience Mindset Matters More Than Ever

As Nat Cat Losses Mount A Resilience Mindset Matters More Than Ever

1381
Anchor MD Loses Father

Anchor MD Loses Father

1377
Leadway Assurance Leads With ISO/IEC Re-certification

Leadway Assurance Leads With ISO/IEC Re-certification

916
NIID: Dare Project To Take back Motor Policy From Touts Still Surging Despite Odds

NIID: Dare Project To Take back Motor Policy From Touts Still Surging Despite Odds

860
PenCom Trigger Lifts Transfer System Off The Starting Block With Split Responsibilities

Pension Funds Encounter First Waterfall

357
Old Mutual Points Nigerians To Insurance-backed Savings Plans To Hedge Economic Volatilities

Old Mutual Points Nigerians To Insurance-backed Savings Plans To Hedge Economic Volatilities

321
Linkage Assurance Aligns With Brokers For Growth

Linkage Assurance Aligns With Brokers For Growth

255
NAICOM Head office

Insurers Claims Paid In 2022 Q4 Increases By 18%, N244.3bn Obligation To Customers

March 24, 2023
NAICOM Regulation Stirs Clear Of Wild Spin Focuses On Mid-Point With Policyholders And Operators

Nigeria’s Insurance Industry Gross Premium Muscle Lifts N776.2bn To Closs 2022

March 23, 2023
Image Spin: Diipo Olarenwaju Says Blockers Of Loss Adjusters Vital Role Will Be Challenged

Image Spin: Diipo Olarenwaju Says Blockers Of Loss Adjusters Vital Role Will Be Challenged

March 23, 2023
Tax Administrators Charged To Match The Pace Of Global Technological Advancements

Tax Administrators Charged To Match The Pace Of Global Technological Advancements

March 21, 2023
Ojumah’ Exploits Earn Induction Into Sanlam Pan Africa Council Of Elders

Ojumah’ Exploits Earn Induction Into Sanlam Pan Africa Council Of Elders

March 20, 2023

FIRS Feast Of MoU Snaps UK Counterpart

March 18, 2023
Guinea Insurance Sets For Return To Profit Turf

Guinea Insurance Sets For Return To Profit Turf

March 18, 2023
Image Spin: Farewell For Omolola Adekunle Bankole

Image Spin: Farewell For Omolola Adekunle Bankole

March 17, 2023
Seplat Energy Says Allegations Against CEO, Board Untrue, Misleading

Seplat Energy Says Allegations Against CEO, Board Untrue, Misleading

March 16, 2023
Transactional Risk Insurance Now Mainstream Product – Report

Transactional Risk Insurance Now Mainstream Product – Report

March 15, 2023

Recent News

NAICOM Head office

Insurers Claims Paid In 2022 Q4 Increases By 18%, N244.3bn Obligation To Customers

March 24, 2023
NAICOM Regulation Stirs Clear Of Wild Spin Focuses On Mid-Point With Policyholders And Operators

Nigeria’s Insurance Industry Gross Premium Muscle Lifts N776.2bn To Closs 2022

March 23, 2023
Image Spin: Diipo Olarenwaju Says Blockers Of Loss Adjusters Vital Role Will Be Challenged

Image Spin: Diipo Olarenwaju Says Blockers Of Loss Adjusters Vital Role Will Be Challenged

March 23, 2023
Tax Administrators Charged To Match The Pace Of Global Technological Advancements

Tax Administrators Charged To Match The Pace Of Global Technological Advancements

March 21, 2023
Ojumah’ Exploits Earn Induction Into Sanlam Pan Africa Council Of Elders

Ojumah’ Exploits Earn Induction Into Sanlam Pan Africa Council Of Elders

March 20, 2023

FIRS Feast Of MoU Snaps UK Counterpart

March 18, 2023
Guinea Insurance Sets For Return To Profit Turf

Guinea Insurance Sets For Return To Profit Turf

March 18, 2023
Image Spin: Farewell For Omolola Adekunle Bankole

Image Spin: Farewell For Omolola Adekunle Bankole

March 17, 2023
Seplat Energy Says Allegations Against CEO, Board Untrue, Misleading

Seplat Energy Says Allegations Against CEO, Board Untrue, Misleading

March 16, 2023
Transactional Risk Insurance Now Mainstream Product – Report

Transactional Risk Insurance Now Mainstream Product – Report

March 15, 2023
Over 2,100 RSA Holders Make Maiden Dash For Transfer Window

PenOp Creates Bastion Of Effective Leadership For Pension Professionals

March 14, 2023
Allianz Combines Commercial Insurance Divisions

Allianz Combines Commercial Insurance Divisions

March 14, 2023
Preferred PenCom Logo

PenCom Knocks Lagos For Consistent Failure To Pay N2bn Monthly Commitment To Retirees

March 13, 2023
Guinea Insurance Takes The Stride Of Fresh N900m Capital

Guinea Insurance Takes The Stride Of Fresh N900m Capital

March 9, 2023
Business Post

We connect brands with buyers and sellers of insurance, pension and also project insurance and allied Businesses to the trending generation. We help the various public to adapt to the constant changes as it would impact, and also enable advertisers to connect, engage and target opportunities on line , in print and in person.

Browse by Category

  • Business Unlimited
  • Feature
  • Insurance
  • News
  • OIL & ENERGY
  • Pension
  • Travel

Recent News

NAICOM Head office

Insurers Claims Paid In 2022 Q4 Increases By 18%, N244.3bn Obligation To Customers

March 24, 2023
NAICOM Regulation Stirs Clear Of Wild Spin Focuses On Mid-Point With Policyholders And Operators

Nigeria’s Insurance Industry Gross Premium Muscle Lifts N776.2bn To Closs 2022

March 23, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 BusinessPost

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Insurance
  • Business Unlimited
  • OIL & ENERGY
  • Feature
  • News
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2023 BusinessPost

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In